Reliable brand-name countertop ice maker producing 26 lbs of bullet ice daily
Frigidaire EFIC189: The reliable choice for everyday bullet ice production
The Frigidaire EFIC189 at $130 is the benchmark mid-price countertop ice maker. At 26 lbs of bullet ice per day with 7-minute cycle times and two cube sizes, the specs match what budget brands offer — but you're buying Frigidaire's service infrastructure, brand warranty, and a design that has a proven track record. For buyers who want confidence in their appliance, the EFIC189 earns the $20–30 premium over generic alternatives.
What works
Frigidaire is an established appliance brand with real warranty and service support. If the EFIC189 malfunctions, you have recourse — a real service center, a recognized warranty process, and parts availability that budget brands can't match. For a countertop appliance you plan to use daily, this matters over a 3–5 year ownership period.
The 7-minute cycle time is efficient — comparable to faster budget models. Two ice sizes let you choose between smaller ice for faster chilling in a glass and larger cubes that melt more slowly in a cocktail. The compact footprint fits on most counters without demanding excessive space.
Consistent ice quality with minimal hollow-core defects is another area where established brands outperform budget alternatives — the ice the EFIC189 produces is dense and clear.
What doesn't
Bullet ice is bullet ice — if you want the soft, chewable nugget ice that's become popular in specialty coffee shops and restaurants, this isn't your machine. The GE Profile Opal 2.0 ($550) is the nugget ice answer.
Ice melts if not used quickly, as with all countertop ice makers — the bin isn't refrigerated. This is inherent to the product category, not specific to the EFIC189.
Who should buy this
Anyone who wants a reliable daily-use countertop ice maker with brand confidence. If you've considered budget alternatives but want the assurance of Frigidaire's backing, the EFIC189 is the straightforward recommendation.
Who should look elsewhere
Budget priority with basic ice needs: Silonn ($80) or Kismile ($90). High-volume needs: Frigidaire EFIC452-SS ($250) at 40 lbs/day. Nugget ice: GE Profile Opal 2.0 ($550).